Books Business Design Games Hardware Internet Utilities Text Other

Moore's Omnibus Mac Email Client Roundup - 2003 Edition

Email Clients A-L

Email Clients M-N

Email Clients O-Z

Friday, January 31, 2003


By Applelinks Contributing Editor Charles W. Moore

It's been a year and a half half since my last Mac POP 3 email client roundup article was posted, and it continues to be one of my most often referenced aechives in response to reader queries. A fair bit of water has passed under the proverbial bridge in the past 18 months, so I figured it's time for an updated piece on the topic.

In the 2001 email client roundup, I speculated about what effect Apple's bundling of the Mail app.client in OS X might have on third-party email application development for the Mac. Happily, it doesn't seem to have hurt developer interest. All of the major players are still in the game, and a crop of newcomers as well. Indeed, I expect there has never been as much choice in email client software for the Mac platform as there are two-day -- at least for OS X.

A few of the smaller Classic OS email programs have fallen by the wayside, which I guess is not surprising, and some that are still available, such as the old Eudora Light 3 (no longer supported, but downloadable) are increasingly marginalized by their lack of support for SMTP authentication. This is a trend that presumably will continue, although there are still a few clients that will even support 68k Macs.

Innovation-wise, the main focus recently has been on spam filtering, as the struggle to keep the spammer bottom-feeders at bay continues ad infinitum. Other new or different ideas are incorporated in the likes of Nisus Email's several unique features, and Zoe -- a new freeware OSX email client that works in a Web browser (Internet Explorer or Mozilla so far).

As with the previous roundup article, I've included only applications that can serve as full, standard POP 3 email client applications that can send, receive, and archive email, while other email utilities. that may do more limited things like checking to see if there is mail on your server were left out. I make no undertaking that this guide is 100 percent comprehensive, but I have tried to find every currently available Mac email application that meets the criteria outlined above. Apologies in advance for any inadvertant exclusions.

The email clients appear here in alphabetical order. Which Mac OS platforms they support are noted. I have used some of these applications listed, but not all of them by a long shot, so these brief overviews should not be construed as reviews. Links to full reviews of the applications (in some cases older versions than the current offerings) that I have tested will be provided.

With so many choices available, you should be able to find an email client that will set your needs and tastes too a "T".

***
Eudora 5.2
Eudora Light 3.1.3
GNUMail 1.1.0pre1 Cocoa Email Client For GNUstep and Mac OS X
GyazMail 0.9.8.3 Cocoa Email Client

***

Eudora 5.2

(OS X; Classic PPC)

This latest and most powerful version of the venerable Eudora email client is in my opinion the all-round cream of the crop in full-featured, heavy-duty, free, e-mail clients. Indeed, were I obliged to use just one email application, it would have to be Eudora 5.2. Eudora has every feature you are likely to need in an email client, and a lot more besides. Other clients may do particular tasks better than Eudora -- for example, Nisus Email's wonderful one-click messaging and OS X Mail's spam filtering -- but few, if any other clients handle all aspects of email management as comprehensively well as Eudora does.

I like the way that Eudora archives saved messages in categorized, draggable, and easy to identify mailbox files that can be opened and searched with a word-processor or text editor. I have dragged Eudora mailboxes around among various versions of Eudora from the old Eudora Light 1.5 that I used with System 6, to the most recent release of Eudora 5.2. That kind of flexibility is tough to beat.

Eudora features:
• Eudora is a standalone email program that works with any ISP that uses standard Internet email protocols.Supports SMTP, POP and IMAP servers
• Multiple mailboxes
• Offline reading and replying
• Supports MIME
• An Internet email software program for managing email (especially good for moderate and heavy email users).
• An email program that resides on the user's desktop
• An email program that synchronizes very quickly with Eudora for the Palm.
• Eudora Sharing Protocol (ESP): allows users to automatically sync files to keep family, friends and co-workers up to date.
• MoodWatch: a fun new feature that warns users about flame content in outgoing and incoming emails.
• Email Usage Stats: offers personal and interesting insight to a user's day-to-day email activity and patterns.
• Import enhancements: Easy import from other common email clients.
• 3 Modes: Eudora is licensed in three ways -- Sponsored mode, Paid mode and Light mode. All three modes are accessible within the application once you've installed and launched it.

In Sponsored mode, Eudora displays ads. We have done our best to present the ads in a way that respects the work you do in email. By allowing Eudora to display ads, you get the full power of Eudora for free and we can still pay our bills. Sponsored mode users are not entitled to technical support.

In Paid mode, Eudora does not display ads, and you get the full power of Eudora. if you have a paid and registered version of Eudora 5.x that is less than twelve months old, you can upgrade at no additional charge. Paid mode users are entitled to technical support.

In Light mode, Eudora has many fewer features, but is free of charge and without ads. Light mode users are not entitled to technical support.

If you are already using Eudora in Paid mode, please make sure it is registered before upgrading. You must have purchased and registered your current copy within the last 12 months to continue using Eudora in Paid mode.

Paid and sponsored modes include a built-in spellhecker and more sophisticated message filtering.

Eudora 5.2 runs on Macintosh PowerPC or better.
Requires Mac OS System 8.6 - 9.x or OS X

Eudora 5.2 supports only Power Macs. 680x0 Mac users are limited to the old Eudora Light 3.1.3 software, which is still available from Qualcomm's ftp site, but no longer supported (see below).

Improvements in this latest 5.2.1b2 (puboic beta) version of Eudora include:
• Fixed problem with relative images in mail from IE
• paid and light users can register again
• Making better nicknames out of plain addresses
• fixed crash transferring message opened from search window which was subsequently close
• Treating 452 as though it were 552, which it should be
• Worked around compiler bug causing crashes when changing signature
• Made quitting via apple events a little safer
• Made offline link reminder dialog work again under OS 9.
• Re-enabled the battery check on MacOS X
• Getting headers/footers of non-first messages to print properly
• Fixed crash after aborted mailbox compact from size box
• Fixed up appearance of Offline Link dialogs
• no longer writing out Finder comments under OSX
• Restored Header: labels in filters window under OSX
• Fixed more crashes with more malformed html
• IMAP now obeys list of SASL mechanisms not to use
• Can now forbid a SASL mechanism for just one protocol via protocol:mechanism in setting 12909
• Fixed crash when emsapi plug-in returned format=flowed
• Since OSX doesn't allow dragging by window edges, don't let all of title bar under toolbar
• Dramatic performance boost for HTML save
• Restored PPP control under OS9
• Worked around broken Jaguar Unicode converter that caused some text to look Chinese
• Corrected version string in Get Info for OS X users
• Put icons in the text colors menu, since apple no longer believes in colored text
• Adjustment for broken IMail AUTH PLAIN
• Tolerating broken IMail POP3 AUTH LOGIN extra blank lines behavior
• Fixed crash drawing collapsed address book (OSX control manager bug)
• Fixed crash dragging nickname without notes to desktop
• No more sounds in the font popups in settings
• Made dialogs that know about graphics more tolerant of large folders of TEXT files
• Fixed problem with long wordwise search filters in LDAP
• Improved performance when opening many windows
• Made Eudora consume less cpu when in bg but needing user attention
• Made Eudora more responsive to clicks when in bg needing user attention
• Fixed crash sending digest with missing images

The Paid mode option sells for $39.95 (after a $10 rebate).

System Requirements:
Eudora for Mac OS
• Macintosh PowerPC or better
• Mac OS System 8.1 or later
• Version 5.1bxx for OS X (Carbon, for OS X only) is also available

Eudora 5.2 e-mail software can be downloaded at:
http://www.eudora.com
or
http://www.eudora.com/download/

For my full review of Eudora (5.0) visit:
http://www.applelinks.com/mooresviews/eudora5.shtml

Eudora Light 3.1.3

(Classic PPC; Classic 68k)

Eudora Light it is fast, stable, has an unobtrusive interface, and very few aggravating aspects. Its biggest shortcomings until recently have been its mediocre search engine and filter support, and its non-support of multiple email accounts. However, an increasingly serious deficiency of Eudora Light now that many ISP's and email services (such as Apple's mac.com for instance) are implementing SMTP authentication as an anti-spam measure, and Eudora Light doesn't support authentication. This also means that Eudora fans with 68k Macs are increasingly out of luck.

Those points notwithstanding, for slick, basic email handling, this program still works fine under Mac OS 9.1, although of course there will be OS X version.

As noted above, Eudora Light 3.1.3, is no longer supported by Qualcomm, but still available on the Eudora ftp site if you go looking for it. To save you the trouble, here is the URL:
ftp://ftp.qualcomm.com/eudora/eudoralight/mac/english/
or
ftp://ftp.qualcomm.com/eudora/eudoralight/mac/english/3.1.3/eudoralight313.hqx

GNUMail 1.1.0pre1 Cocoa Email Client For GNUstep and Mac OS X

(OS X)

GNUMail.app is a fully featured mail application running on Linux (or FreeBSD, OpenBSD, etc) and Apple Mac OS X. It uses the GNUstep development framework or Apple Cocoa, which is based on the OpenStep specification provided by NeXT, Inc.. GNUMail.app is licensed under the GPL, and the full sources of the application are available.

GNUMail.app was written from scratch. It uses Pantomime as its mail handling framework.

The current version of GNUMail.app is 1.1.0pre1. This release is quite stable and rich in functionalities and will work well for a day-to-day use.

Version 1.1.0pre1 has the following supported features:
• Multiple POP3 (with APOP support) accounts with local cache support (for leaving messages on server);
• Multiple delivery agents (SMTP or local mailer);
• Mail spool file support for receiving;
• Good IMAP support with local caching;
• Full RFC822 and RFC2822 support;
• Read, compose, bounce, reply and forward mails;
• Mailbox management (create, delete, locking and transfer messages) using the Berkeley mbox format;
• Personal preferences management;
• MIME support (decode and encode);
• A full MIME types manager;
• Quoted Printable and BASE64 support;
• Address Book with groups support;
• Find Panel with regular expressions support;
• Automatic or manual fetching of your mails (user's choice);
• Powerful filters that supports regular expressions;
• GPG (PGP) support through a bundle;
• Messages threading;
• And more...

Changed since the last release of GNUMail.app:
• Reworked Preferences panel (now has a Standard / Expert views)
• Now uses the OS X 10.2 Address Book by default under OS X and better auto-completion support when composing new mails under OS X and GNUstep
• Added DnD support for attachments in the compose window
• New Console (Window->Console) and new multi-threading code
• Better OS X integration (using sheets, spell checking, etc)
• New About panel
• Better PGP support
• Lots of other features, bug fixes and refactorings

System requirements:
• Mac OS X 10.2.x
• Developer Tools (if NOT using the Mac OS X disk image)

For more information, visit:
http://www.collaboration-world.com/gnumail/

GyazMail 0.9.8.3 Cocoa Email Client

(OS X)

GyazMail is e-mail client software for Mac OS X. GyazMail is developed from scratch to be simple, easy-to-use e-mail client with many features, based on Cocoa framework. Currently it is still in development stage, but progressing every day.

The main features of GyazMail are as follows.
• Multiple accounts
• Management of messages by one file per message (RFC 822 format)
• Many character sets support, including UTF-8 (Unicode)
• Main window with 2 or 3 panes
• Message threading support
• Message search on multiple criteria, in specified folders
• Message rules and filters
• Template for outgoing messages
• Message queueing
• POP3 (APOP), SMTP (POP before SMTP, SMTP AUTH) support
• SSL (Secure Sockets Layer) support
• RFC 2822(822) support
• MIME support
• Remote mail
• Key assignment customization
• Cooperation with Apple's address book (Mac OS X 10.2 or later)
• Automatic address completion
• Cooperation with the dock

• 3 paned display (jpg, 156KB)
• 2 paned display (jpg, 149KB)
• 2 paned display with more search options dialog (jpg, 144KB)

New in this version:
• The problem that Account ID and Password containing the character "%" may be unable to use, has been fixed (fixing in 0.9.8.2 was incomplete).
Ê
System requirements:
• GyazMail requires Mac OS X 10.1 or later (Using an address book features, Mac OS X 10.2 or later is required).

GyazMail is freeware Ê
Ê Ê
For more information, visit:
http://homepage.mac.com/gooichi/GyazMail/

For a mini-review of GyazMail (version 0.8.1) see OS X Odyssey 162:
http://www.applelinks.com/news/odyssey/

***

Email Clients M-N

Email Clients O-Z

Charles W. Moore

Email This Article - Comment On This Article

.

Reader Specials

Server Racks Online:
Apple Xserve CompatibleServer Racks and Universal Network Racks
42U KVM Switch Solutions:
High-End Mac and Multi-Platform KVM Matrix switching solutions!
Digital Camera Online:
Great prices on Digital Cameras and accessories!
KVM Switches Online:
Great prices on Mac KVM Switches from the leading manufacturers!
LCD Monitors Online:
Great prices on LCD Monitors from the leading manufacturers!
LCD Projectors Online:
Shop online for LCD Projectors from the leading manufacturers!
USB 2.0 Online:
Great prices on USB 2.0 products from the leading manufacturers

Serious Business Software:
Accounting, Sales, Inventory, CRM, Shipping, Payroll & more!

KVM Switch solutions for MACs:
DAXTEN is a KVM switch, KVM extender and monitor splitter specialist for PC, SUN and MAC applications from name brand manufacturers - offices worldwide.

The "Think Different Store: The iPod Accessories Store - iPod cases, iPod mini, iPod photo, speakers, itrip, inMotion, Soundstage and all other iPod accessories

Earn Cash with the ThinkDifferent Store Affiliates Program

Need A Web Site?
Applelinks Web Hosting Starting at 19.95 a Month

iTunes_RGB_9mm

.

iTunes_RGB_9mm

Cool Mac Gear


iPod 1G-2G
iPod 3G
iPod 4G
iPod Mini
PowerBook-iBook
Keyboard Skins
Garageband