TransPod All-In-One Car Solution

5251

Provides: Power, support and FM transmission for Port connected iPods (including the new mini iPods

Developer: DLO

Requirements: An iPod, a car with an FM radio, and a car power source

Retail Price: $99.99



So, you've got an iPod (or an iPod mini) and you want to play it while riding around in your car. For one thing, it's illegal in most states to have plugs, buds, or earphones on while driving, so that shouldn't be an option. There are FM transmitters to broadcast your iPod's music, but then you need that extra cable to get power into your iPod to save on battery power. Lastly, how do you support your iPod when many cup holders don't have solid bottoms. Well the TransPod FM does it all.


Seldom have I been so jazzed about a product that I had to show it to everyone, strangers included. The concept is very straightforward: you plug the power end of the TransPod into your car's power-plug (formally known as the cigarette lighter). The other end is a holster that you slip your iPod into. There are self-stick pads of varying thickness that you place within the holster to accommodate 10, 15 or 20GB iPods, one of the thicker 30 GB iPods, or the small iPod mini. The pad insures that the iPod has no "wiggle" room inside the holster.


The TransPod not only supports your iPod, it provides power to the holster and doubles (or is that triples?) as an FM transmitter. The TransPod can broadcast the full FM frequency. The way it works is you dial around your car's radio until you find a region that doesn't have a radio station playing. For best response, you should find a signal that has at least one blank station on both sides (e.g., if 89.1, 89.3 and 89.5 are all clear, so you set your FM radio and the TransPod to 89.3). On the third image further down, you can clearly see the two buttons used to set the TransPod's frequency. On the image below, you can see the LCD screen where you can easily discern the station the TransPod is set to broadcast.


Included with the holster are a variety of connection devices:





In the middle of the above image is the TransPod holster. To the left is a more typical car's power-outlet plug which is to be used with the squat "dash" support just above and a bit to the left of the holster. To the right of the holster are two reticulated arms for standard use.


On the back of the holster is a hole which all the supports screw into with a quarter turn. On the right in the image below is the "dash" support. Showing the image below, it is easy to see how the holster inserts into, and rotates 90° to lock in place. The dash support is used when the regular support arms cannot be used for whatever reason. The dash support is mounted (screws are provided) directly on your dashboard. The power supply is inserted in the black plug receiver just barely seen above the bottom screw hole.





However, assuming that you do not need the dash support, the arm support comes in two pieces (although you may only need one). As seen below, this is the basic arm support in my car (the basic arm is the one closest to the holster shown in the top image). The basic arm has the power-plug plug at one end.





While this does work well, the problem I found is that the iPod is held straight out. As you can see, the design of my car places the iPod more to the passenger's side than the driver's side. As such, it was not all that easy for me to see the iPod's screen. To drive while straining your neck to see what album or song you are selecting can be dangerous.


Although you may not need it for space reasons, if you attach the second arm support to the first, it has one added advantage over the basic arm. The second arm support has a ball-gymbol as its last component. This means that you can rotate the holster from side to side (and up-and-down). This is different from the rest of the reticulations which only provide up-or-down movement.


As can be seen in the image below, the iPod is held much higher and is rotated toward the driver. This image also clearly shows the two up-and-down buttons on the side of the holster that are used to "tune" the transmitter to the null station you select on your radio. The small LCD screen on the bottom front of the holster is where you can (easily) see what station your TransPod is tuned to.






My wife's car has a completely different power-plug mount. The TransPod had no difficulty providing clearance and good visibility. With all the reticulations and pivots, it should not be too difficult to find some position and angle that works well with your car.







Lastly, if you look closely on the image above, on the right side of the holster, just to the right of the steering wheel, is a small silver dot/hole. This is an earphone jack. Some car stereos have an input option where you can obtain a special cable and attach a phone jack in the TransPod and insert the other end into your stereo and bypass the FM transmitter entirely. Alternatively, if your car has a cassette tape as part of the radio, you can obtain one of the car cassette adaptors to bypass the FM transmitter approach.


While the TransPod can broadcast the entire FM spectrum, I found the best sound was achieved by staying below 90- 92. Above that frequency I found the singer's "s" sounds to be very raspy (similar to the sound of AM stations that are not set properly "on" the station). Above 100, I found a lot of extra noises, buzzes, and occasional hums. These problems, as I'm to understand, are more due to the physics of low power FM transmitters than this unit in specific.


One other problem I found, again due to the physics of radio, is that, when weaving around very hilly regions where all stations are distant (I was on a driving trip when this happened), occasionally a distant station would be bounced into my radio providing competition to the TransPod. On the other hand, I occasionally found that when I turned the iPod and TransPod off, a station was broadcasting on the same frequency that I was just using. This shows the reasonable strength that the TransPod provides.


Keep in mind that I live in Los Angeles, a city that has FM stations up and down the wazoo. I have had no problems finding a sufficient amount of empty space to play my iPod and have had no problems enjoying my music.


So, until car makers start supplying an iPod dock as part of a car's features, using an FM transmitter of some kind is the best way one can use an iPod in one's car. And, if you do use this approach, the TransPod is the best mechanism I've seen to do this with.


I do have one complaint, albeit small; there is no manual or guidance. The closest DLO comes is a card in the back of the bubble pack showing the pieces with absolute minimal descriptive information. While it is possible to work this out without detailed explanations, an 8.5 x 11 paper providing some "use" explanation and suggestions would have been an easy addition.






Applelinks Rating




Order the TransPod All-In-One Car Solution


___________ Gary Coyne has been a scientific glassblower for over 30 years. He's been using Macs since 1985 (his first was a fat Mac) and has been writing reviews of Mac software and hardware since 1995.



Tags: Reviews ď iPod Reviews ď

Login † or † Register † †

I have to disagree. I had one of these for awhile. Clunky, picks up all kinds of engine noise, very delicate hanging out there with all it’s weight on the cigarette lighter. The FM frequency is adjustable by knob and has to be tuned constantly. If you live in a major metro area, you’ll have a hard time finding a free channel. If you are traveling, you’ll have a hard time keeping it tuned, interference free. Much more hassle than it’s worth. I use a Griffin iTrip and it’s much the same without all the crap. Use a cassette adapter instead or a line-in if at all possible.

Jeb,

You have a right to disagree and I’m sorry your experience was not as good as mine. I don’t know what major metro area you live in, but I live in Los Angeles (as mentioned in my article), and I belive that qualifies as a major metro area. Yes, my dial isn’t full of empty space, but I found several areas where I had very good reception. Also, as explained in my article, lower frequencies (88 - 91) provide better sound than higher frequencies (95-107). Yes, that does further limit the possible broadcast stations, but that is a limitation of all of the FM broadcasting iPod connectors.

As far as the wiggling, this is a subject I meant to cover in my article but forgot: I was very impressed with how little bouncing there was. Sure, the longer the arm the greater the wiggle, but as I tend not to do off-road driving, and my car has reasonable shocks (it is 11 years old now) I was not concerned bout the TransPOD breaking off from too much bouncing.

And as I also mentioned in my article, yes--if you want the best reception, use a cassette adapter or go line-in if possible but that would require more cables and things to plug in. One of the big benifits of the TransPOD is that you plug it into the power adapter, plug your iPod into the TransPOD and you are done. For years I had a cassette player that I’d plug the power adapter in, then slip the cassette adapter in the radio, then balance the CD player in one of the drawers on my dashboard and with wires all over the place I was ready. This was nothing I could deal with by myself and could only use this when my wife was with me. I can deal with my iPod in the TransPOD all by myself very easily.

The best solution will come when cars start adding iPod docks as options to consumers. Hey, it could happen.

Again though, as far as the TransPOD goes, is it problem free? Of course not, but it has less limitatiions and more advantages than any other product/solution I’ve seen.

But as always, YMMV

Best,

Gary Coyne

What bugs me is that, despite all the problems that you originally described and acknowledged later, you still found it fit to give the TransPod a five-A rating.  That just sounds too positive to me, as if it would be the top choice among all in-car iPod solutions.

Now, true, it’s the only one I know of that powers & transmits while holding the iPod, which in a twisted sense puts the TransPod in a class all its own.  However, it just doesn’t seem to be doing the job as well as other products.  A combination of the iTrip, Belkin’s TuneDock, and a power adapter can do the job for the same price or less, along with the flexibility of using the iTrip anywhere outside the car as well.  Plus, having the cradle supported by the power socket just doesn’t seem good in the long run.

Anyway, I’m starting to ramble.  I’d put the rating at 3 A’s (other products barely deserve 1, to be honest), since other still-imperfect solutions do better, and wait to see if something like Alpine’s upcoming iPod interface is really the be-all, end-all of products for mobile iPod use.  That’s what the 5-A rating should be reserved for, really—no possible problems, no issues, so-good-it-can’t-be-beat products that would relegate previous attempts to a shoebox under the bed.

Leland,

You do not ramble and very succinctly get to the heart of the host of complications for reviewers. What factors do/should I weigh when giving a rating?

Speaking for myself (but I feel that the following is followed in part by most reviewers) I consider (in no particular order) how well the product performs in relation to what was promised, the cost, the ease of use, quality of documentation (including paper and/or PDF), how it rates compared to the competition, and anything else that may come up during my testing. The “weight” of the product does not (necessarily) have an effect on the rating. E.g., Adobe Photoshop does not get any bonus points because it’s big and important (which it is) and a plug in for Photoshop doesn’t get any fewer--each is rated for what it is, what it is expected to do, and how well it does it.

I cannot fault any product for limitations in physics. Cars make subtle electronic noise in the higher FM frequencies making all the FM transmitters limited to some degree. I cannot fault the concept of airplanes just because when the engines fail the planes fall to earth--we still have gravity to deal with.

As far as your suggestion of the iTrip + TuneDock and Power Adapter, I just did a quick check on the web and came up to a price of just over $90. Yup, that’s cheaper than the TransPod but now you have three things to deal with and the iPod as opposed to one thing to deal with and the iPod.

(Due to space limitations, I have to split my comments in two:, part II coming next.

Gary Coyne)

Part II

For my book, convenience to user is also part of the equation. One other convenience is that you tune the TransPod on the TransPod--you do not need to leave your tunes (or at least the tune window) in your iPod to select a new station. So, as I drive along, if I start to get interference, I tune my car radio up or down a station or two, press the TransPod’s radio trans button up or down a station or two and I’m done--I can easily see the station on my car radio and my TransPod’s large LED screen--very convenient.

In your statement “That just sounds too positive to me, as if it would be the top choice among all in-car iPod solutions.” That’s exactly what I found. For me, when you weigh all the good and bad points, the advantages and disadvantages, I find the TransPod the top choice among all in-car iPod solutions.

But I did very clearly state that the best sound will be achieved with a cassette adapter which the TransPod does support-- but newer cars often do not have a cassette players and it’s one more thing to deal with.

I also look forward to the ultimate solution: iPod Docks built into cars. At the rate that iPods are being accepted, I actually expect that at some point.

I do not insist that you agree with me. I certainly have read other reviewer’s reviews of products I’ve reviewed and found areas of agreement and disagreement. I see no reason why Mac products should be any different from say, movie reviews--different people see different things.

Best and thanks for the opportunity to talk about reviewing,

Gary Coyne

I know, I know, the TransPod does as promised, I’ll give it that much.  If I were the one doing the reviewing, my rating would be based on how well it executes the general concept of In-Car iPod Thing (or something more poetic than that).  Maybe I’d break it down a bit, saying that although it does what it can within the limitations of an FM transmitter on a stalk, it’s still not without its faults.  A five-A rating from me would equate with “faultless”.

But, I’m real picky, too.

I’m sure you’ve seen the custom iPod docks people have been putting in their cars, along with VW’s iPod option, but even I think that they don’t really count as a fair comparison to the TransPod.  After all, the sky’s the limit when custom work is involved. 

If I could weigh in on the Transpod FM review & subsequent debate… I bought one yesterday and returned it today. My biggest gripe was sound volume and quality. Using the dock connector should yield much greater volume than the headphone jack. I had to turn the radio volume up all the way to get what I would consider a “loud” volume. And clarity of sound was just plain bad. I was sorely tempted to keep it because it was mounted in my vehicle so handily, but @ $100 after I already bought a Belkin TuneDock, I decided it wasn’t worth $100 and still have to use a cassette adapter. Sound quality is probably typical for FM transmitters, just not good enough for me.

The Monster iCarPlay is an all-in-one FM transmitter and iPod charger.

It is cheaper and it looks a lot better.

http://www.monstercable.com/computer/mac.asp#iPod

your review and your ratings are disparate.

and you seem to be too personally invested in this review..

How in the hell can you review a product with low marks, give it a 5 A rating AND sell it in your own store at ThinkDifferentStore.com?? Very fishy.

Just now bought the iCarPlay, and I can’t recommend it.  It’s going back for a refund tomorrow.

The small size & ease of use are great; the lack of signal quality makes it unusable for anything but rock n’ roll, and even then, the poor highs & occasional static bursts detract from the music.

I’m debating between the ICELink and Alpine’s upcoming AiNet interface.  But I digress…

I work in retail and have seen many of these items returned. They transmitter is subquality, in the views of several customers, and the system for holding it seems too “little kid toy"-ish. It’s not pleasant to look at nor is it all that convienant. I’d recommend going with griffith’s iTrip. The transmitter pulls power off of the ipod and most people don’t drive 8 hours total in a day, much less in one stretch. For a long hall get a deditcated power converter for the lighter plug or the battery powered add-on for the ipod. Much, much better solution.

I have a TransPod for the original iPods, and while it is nice and convenient, it’s also a hell of a lot of trouble. With the iTrip, once I found a station, it worked for my driveable area with minimal noise. The transpod I have to keep adjusting in just the 10 minute drive from home to work. I think part of this could be solved if the power of the transmitter could be upped, but I doubt that’s very legal. On top of that, the tuning dial is very loose and is constantly loosing it’s point.

At this point, i would say the best solution is the iTrip, a dedicated power adapter and one of those magic stick pads for dashboards.

Anyone have a dedicated power adapter they want to sell?

I couldnt get mine to work...when I first plugged it into my BMW 325i it blew both the lighter fuse and the fuse of the Transpod (inside the adapter).  Bought it online and will see if Netalog is reponsive with their customer support.

hi, JTW, what happened to your BMW ? i plug it into my land rover & there’s no signal at all ,,,,,,,,,,,, how does it work ???

If it doesn’t even light up, then likely the fuse has been blown in either the car, the device, or both.  I had to replace fuses to finally get it to work.  All in all it wasn’t a bad solution, but the ICELink is much nicer and I have moved on to that.  I only use the Transpod now in the wife’s car or when travelling on vacation.

jtw

thanks jtw, i managed to get it work.... i discovered that i just didnt stick it into the lighter enough, now its’ working very well, i think its’ marvellous, very good quality..... thanks

joe

i have a transpod 3 and the first time that i used it it worked fine.  I have a 2004 ACURA MDX. nOW IT CONSTANTLY BLOWS THE CIG LIGHTERS FUSE EVERY TIME THAT I PLUG IT IN.  WHY WON’T IT WORK.’’
i HAVE HEARD THAT THERE IS A FUSE IN THE TRANSPOD.  WHERE IS IT AND WHERE DO I GET REPLACEMENT FUSES.  THANKS

the fuse is in the thing you plug into your lighter.  Just unscrew the tip and there it is.  You can buy replacement fuses at any hardware store or even radio shack.  Not sure why the Transpod blows fuses but it does all the time.

My Belkin power adapter & P.I.E. audio adapter haven’t blown anything…

I must have a really old version of the transpod...it has a rotary dial on the left side , a H/M/L freq. selector on the face, and no LED readout; I have a really hard time figuring out the frequency parameters and maintaining a clear signal when and if I get it to work...any suggestions?

I must have a really old version of the transpod...it has a rotary dial on the left side , a H/M/L freq. selector on the face, and no LED readout; I have a really hard time figuring out the frequency parameters and maintaining a clear signal when and if I get it to work...any suggestions?

“I must have a really old version of the transpod...”

Well, I hate to say it, but they must have revised the TransPod when they saw how many problems people were having with the version you own; and, therefore, the only way to improve it would be to get a new model.

Follow Us

Twitter Facebook RSS! http://www.joeryan.com Joe Ryan

Most Popular

iPod




iPhone

iLife

Reviews

Software Updates

Games

Hot Topics

Hosted by MacConnect - Macintosh Web Hosting and Mac Mini Colocation                                                    Contact | Advanced Search|