HomeThinkDifferentStoreMacBoardsAdvertisingRSS SyndicationNewsletterContact

iTunes_RGB_9mm

Cool Mac Gear


iPod Video
iPod nano
iPod 1G-2G
iPod 3G
iPod 4G
iPod Mini
PowerBook-iBook
Garageband

Special Report
Copyright Wars Legislation Goes To Bat For The Consumer’s Interest

Friday, October 4, 2002


By Applelinks Contributing Editor Charles W. Moore

Congresswoman Zoe Lofgren (D-CA) has introduced legislation designed to protect consumer’s ability to enjoy digital copyrighted material. Lofgren’s bill, the “Digital Choice and Freedom Act of 2002,” gives lawful consumers the ability to make personal uses of digital entertainment such as music, movies, and books.  In addition, the bill recognizes that digital piracy will never be truly solved until consumers are given an affordable, reliable, legitimate and secure alternative.

“Consumers need a voice in this debate. Right now, it is the entertainment industry versus the technology industry, and the consumers are watching from the sidelines,” said Lofgren. “Consumers have rights and expectations that cannot be ignored by industry goliaths.”

Traditionally, copyright laws have tried to balance the interests of copyright holders in the control and exploitation of their works with the interests of society in the free flow of ideas, information and commerce.  Lofgren seeks to maintain that balance in the digital age by finding ways to prevent and punish digital pirates without treating every consumer as a criminal.  Current proposals to combat digital piracy focus primarily on “locking-down” content and controlling how consumers use content that has dramatically altered the balance of copyright law.  Lofgren’s bill seeks to restore that balance.

For over one hundred years, copyright law has aspired to strike a fair balance between the interests of copyright holders in the control and exploitation of their works with the interests of society in the free flow of ideas, information and commerce.  The great challenge today is to maintain that balance in the digital age by finding ways to prevent and punish digital pirates without treating every consumer as one.  The Digital Choice and Freedom Act achieves this, and does so without utilizing government mandates or other prescriptive measures that ultimately only serve to stifle innovation.

Specifically, the Act:

• Clarifies that America’s historic principles of fair use – protected under Section 107 of the Copyright Act – apply to analog and digital transmissions.

• Allows lawful consumers to make backup copies and display digital works on the devices of their choice.

• Protects lawful consumers by prohibiting non-negotiable shrink-wrap licenses that limit their rights and expectations.

• Clarifies that lawful consumers can sell or give away their copies of digital works, just like they can with traditional hard media.

• Protects lawful consumers by permitting them to bypass technical measures that impede their rights and expectations. 

• Provides flexibility for content owners to develop new and innovative ways to protect their content and enable lawful uses. 

Current proposals to combat digital piracy focus primarily on “locking-down” content in ways that threaten the traditional balance.  In addition to fighting piracy, technical protection measures can give copyright holders the power to control how consumers use the movies, music and books they lawfully purchase.  The DCFA seeks to restore the balance while recognizing that the problem of digital piracy will never be truly solved until consumers are given a legitimate alternative that is affordable, reliable, secure, and respectful of their reasonable rights and expectations. 

For example, Lofgren’s bill will allow consumers to make copies of purchased digital media for use in their car, computer or mobile device.  Lofgren ultimately believes her proposal will not only benefit consumers.  A legitimate alternative that respects consumer rights and expectations will spur technological innovation and lead to greater copyright protection.

“Enhancing consumer rights and technology development are the key to copyright protection,” said Lofgren. “We need innovative technologies to help the consumer stay within the limits of the law and to protect the rights of copyright holders.  I believe Silicon Valley is poised to work with consumers and the entertainment industry to create the needed balance for the digital world.”

Lofgren’s release notes that:

“Consumers have shown that they want to use content on new and exciting platforms, like MP3 players.  They should not have to ask copyright holders for permission to do so.

“Ultimately, this proposal will not only benefit consumers.  A legitimate alternative that respects consumer rights and expectations is the only lasting cure for digital piracy.  And providing room for technological innovation will lead to economic recovery and jobs in the Valley.       

“Today, when a consumer purchases a book, they are free to lend their copy to a friend or family member, or to sell their copy to a used books store. Section 4 allows consumers to do the same thing with digital content by extending the first sale doctrine – codified in section 109 of Title 17 – to digital transmissions.  At the same time, it protects copyright holders by restricting such transmissions to a single recipient and requiring the consumer to transmit their copies with copy-control restrictions in place.  Consumers also have to dispose of their copy after they transmit the work to someone else.  After all, if you sell your hard copy of a book, you no longer possess the book. 

“Contrary to the intent of Congress, Section 1201 of the DMCA has been used to prohibit all users – even lawful ones – from circumventing technical restrictions for any reason.  As a result, lawful consumers cannot legally circumvent technological restrictions, even if they are simply trying to exercise a fair use or to utilize a work on a different digital media device. 

“The authors of the DMCA never intended to create such a dramatic shift in the balance.  As the House Judiciary Report accompanying the DMCA stated:  “[A]n individual [should] not be able to circumvent in order to gain unauthorized access to a work, but should be able to do so in order to make fair use of a work which he or she has acquired lawfully”

For a list of the Lofgren bill’s supporters, visit: http://www.house.gov/lofgren/press/107press/021002_supporter.htm

For a full section by section analysis of the bill, visit: http://www.house.gov/lofgren/press/107press/021002_sections.htm

And a big Bravo! to Ms. Lofgren.


Charles W. Moore

Email This Article - Comment On This Article

Recent News
Page: 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5

.

Reader Specials

Server Racks Online:
Apple Xserve CompatibleServer Racks and Universal Network Racks
42U KVM Switch Solutions:
High-End Mac and Multi-Platform KVM Matrix switching solutions!
Digital Camera Online:
Great prices on Digital Cameras and accessories!
KVM Switches Online:
Great prices on Mac KVM Switches from the leading manufacturers!
LCD Monitors Online:
Great prices on LCD Monitors from the leading manufacturers!
LCD Projectors Online:
Shop online for LCD Projectors from the leading manufacturers!
USB 2.0 Online:
Great prices on USB 2.0 products from the leading manufacturers

Serious Business Software:
Accounting, Sales, Inventory, CRM, Shipping, Payroll & more!

KVM Switch solutions for MACs:
DAXTEN is a KVM switch, KVM extender and monitor splitter specialist for PC, SUN and MAC applications from name brand manufacturers - offices worldwide.

The "Think Different Store: The iPod Accessories Store - iPod cases, iPod mini, iPod photo, speakers, itrip, inMotion, Soundstage and all other iPod accessories

Earn Cash with the ThinkDifferent Store Affiliates Program

Need A Web Site?
Applelinks Web Hosting Starting at 19.95 a Month

iTunes_RGB_9mm

iTunes_RGB_9mm

Cool Mac Gear


iPod 1G-2G
iPod 3G
iPod 4G
iPod Mini
PowerBook-iBook
Keyboard Skins
Garageband