HomeThinkDifferentStoreMacBoardsAdvertisingRSS SyndicationNewsletterContact

iTunes_RGB_9mm

Cool Mac Gear


iPod Video
iPod nano
iPod 1G-2G
iPod 3G
iPod 4G
iPod Mini
PowerBook-iBook
Garageband

Special Report
Why Macintosh? Think TCO

Tuesday, May 28, 2002


By Applelinks Contributing Editor Charles W. Moore

Terri Schoone, Director of Instructional Technology for the Urbana School District has posted an excellent article on why the Mac offers superior Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) to institutions. This article is well worth checking out for the large number of links backing up Ms. Schoone’s theses, but the latter is exceptionally well-stated in its own right. Some exerpts:

“...I don’t have the luxury of playing favorites or limiting my options by prejudiced preconceptions. I have to pick the best machine that will enable the school district to provide the most with limited funds and limited support, be reliable, last a relatively long time, be utilized to its potential, and minimize stress and anxiety of technology-novice teachers. In short, I have to consider Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)... Statistics clearly support Macintosh as having the lowest TCO....

“...The time and money spent on repairs of our Macintosh is only a fraction of what is spent on the PCs in the District... The argument that a visit to Best Buy reveals the popularity of PCs and the scarcity of Macs is a perfect example of what is called ‘increasing returns’ in economics and ‘strange attractors’ in a branch of mathematics called ‘chaos theory’....

“To become fixated on the popularity or dominance of a platform in counterproductive. The SKILLS necessary to be productive in the information society are universal regardless of platform. In fact there are more similarities to the systems than the cosmetic differences.....

“The Mac’s ease of use compared to IBM compatibles may be open to debate; the Mac’s comparative ease of networking is not. According to surveys the average time to connect a Macintosh to a network is 10 minutes; the average time to connect an IBM compatible is 45 minutes, with some installations taking more than 10 hours. In an academic environment, networking is crucial: printing, email, library catalog access, Internet access all assume a connection to the network. Preferring Macs makes networking easier.......

“As far as Macintosh only being used in Education, ask yourself if you have your prejudicial blinders on. There is no argument that for small businesses (which makes up the vast majority of industry) and home use that the PC dominates (until recently it has been less expensive than the superiorly engineered Macintosh). But when NASA proposed to standardize to Windows, they had engineers in a revolt. The engineers won and to this day you will find Macintosh on some NASA engineers’ desks. Macintosh dominates the graphic arts fields, including all those computer animated special effects out of Hollywood. Macintosh servers were for a long time only second to Sun Spark stations (Unix OS) as Web Servers.

“....In the schools we have Macintosh machines in use that are over 10 years old. PCs from ten years ago have long since been removed and are no longer supported. A 10 year old PC would be the equivalent of an 8088 or at most a 286, and unable to run any version of Windows, let alone current Web browsers or word processors.”

I can relate. My nine year old 68030 LC 520 is still a useful and productive machine, in daily use by my wife for email, word processing, and even a bit of Web surfing with Netscape 4.04. I also use it for scanning, and as a printer server. My daughter is still using a 1995 vintage PowerBook 5300 as her school machine, and will upgrade slightly to a 1996 technology PowerBook 1400 for college next year. Even PC contemporaries of this 1998 PowerBook WallStreet I’m typing on right now would be compromised trying to run the latest versions of Windows efficiently.

And I’m always amused by ignorant innuendo from PC partisans about the Mac being a “toy” while the PeeCee is a “real computer.” I use a Mac in large part because it lets me get my work done efficiently and with a minimum of support and configuration hassle. The old slogan, “Macintosh, It Just Works! (Windows is just work)” is factually dead-accurate. Deliver me from having to try to work on a PC.

As for NASA, J. L. Williams, Group Lead, DM32/Orbit Flight Dynamics Group, at the NASA/Lyndon B. Johnson Space Center in Houston, Texas has been a The Road Warrior MailBag correspondent on MacOpinion from time to time over the years. Back in 1998 Joe, who was at the time using a PowerBook 5300, wrote:

“I’ve used my machine faithfully every day at work at the Johnson Space Center in Houston. In fact, as I am writing this to you on my 5300cs, I’m sitting on console supporting the current Shuttle mission. I can do pretty much everything with this machine in support of my role as a Rendezvous Guidance and Procedures Officer.”

Got that? PC weenies dis the Mac as a “toy computer,” and this guy is supporting the Space shuttle with a PowerBook 5300!

Actually, Joe upgraded to a Pismo PowerBook in 2000. I’ll bet his TCO for both ‘Books has been a lot less than if he were using Windoze PC notebooks, too.

You can check out Ms. Schoone’s article at:
http://www.cmi.k12.il.us/Urbana/ymac.htm


Charles W. Moore

Email This Article - Comment On This Article

Recent News
Page: 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5

.

Reader Specials

Server Racks Online:
Apple Xserve CompatibleServer Racks and Universal Network Racks
42U KVM Switch Solutions:
High-End Mac and Multi-Platform KVM Matrix switching solutions!
Digital Camera Online:
Great prices on Digital Cameras and accessories!
KVM Switches Online:
Great prices on Mac KVM Switches from the leading manufacturers!
LCD Monitors Online:
Great prices on LCD Monitors from the leading manufacturers!
LCD Projectors Online:
Shop online for LCD Projectors from the leading manufacturers!
USB 2.0 Online:
Great prices on USB 2.0 products from the leading manufacturers

Serious Business Software:
Accounting, Sales, Inventory, CRM, Shipping, Payroll & more!

KVM Switch solutions for MACs:
DAXTEN is a KVM switch, KVM extender and monitor splitter specialist for PC, SUN and MAC applications from name brand manufacturers - offices worldwide.

The "Think Different Store: The iPod Accessories Store - iPod cases, iPod mini, iPod photo, speakers, itrip, inMotion, Soundstage and all other iPod accessories

Earn Cash with the ThinkDifferent Store Affiliates Program

Need A Web Site?
Applelinks Web Hosting Starting at 19.95 a Month

iTunes_RGB_9mm

iTunes_RGB_9mm

Cool Mac Gear


iPod 1G-2G
iPod 3G
iPod 4G
iPod Mini
PowerBook-iBook
Keyboard Skins
Garageband